|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2020 US Presidential Election Related
Lawsuits |
|
|
|
(Public Version 7-10-24) |
(Note: this list is sorted chronologically) |
|
|
|
|
|
# |
Election
Integrity Cases with Trump as Plaintiff |
Date Filed |
Topic * |
Decided on
Merits ** |
State |
Issue(s) |
Disposition |
Ruling Favored |
Date of Last
Order |
Status |
|
|
1 |
Donald J. Trump for Pres., Inc. v. Boockvar, No.
2:20-cv-00966 (Western D PA) |
6/29/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail (Notice/Cure
for Mismatches Missing Signature or Mistakes; Witness Requirements; Failure
to include ID/Doc; etc.) |
Dismissed
- Lack Standing on federal claims; Other claims did not have a statutory
basis |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
10/10/20 |
Closed |
|
|
2 |
Donald J. Trump for President v. Cegavske, No.
2:20-cv-01445 (District NV) |
8/04/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Nevada |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution) |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing and Jurisdiction |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
10/22/20 |
Closed |
|
|
3 |
RNC/Trump v. Miller, No. 06571 EQCV095986 (Iowa District
Court, Linn County) |
8/10/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Iowa |
Vote-by-Mail (pre-populating
ballots should not be allowed) |
Granted
Injunction. Iowa counties were told to send blank ballots |
Trump/GOP |
12/20/20 |
Closed |
|
|
4 |
Donald J. Trump for President v. Murphy, No.
3:20-cv-10753 (District NJ) |
8/19/20 |
RULES |
NO |
New
Jersey |
Governor
mandates all votes to be by mail |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
10/22/20 |
Closed |
|
|
5 |
Donald J. Trump for President et al v. Bullock et al, No.
6:20-cv-00066 (D. Mont.) |
9/02/20 |
RULES |
TBD |
Montana |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that the Governor exceeded his authority, etc.) |
Consolidated
with Lamm case |
See Lamm case |
9/30/20 |
Consolidated |
|
|
6 |
Donald J. Trump for Pres., Inc. v. Philadelphia County
Board of Elections, No. 200902035 (PA Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia
County) |
10/01/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
Poll observers were not allowed at early voting
locations |
Denied on statutory basis |
Election Administrators |
10/23/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for President, Inc. v. Philadelphia
County, No. 983 CD 2020 (Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court) |
10/15/20 |
|
|
7 |
In re November 3, 2020 Gen. Election, No. 149 MM 2020
(Penn. Supreme Court) |
10/04/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Pennsylvania |
Signature
Verification |
Denied
on statutory basis |
Election Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Trump v. Boockvar, No. 20-845 (US Supreme Court) |
12/20/20 |
Vote-by-Mail (Poll
Observer Access; Signature Verification Standards; Notice/Cure for Mismatches
Missing Signature or Mistakes) |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
8 |
Donald J. Trump for President v. Simon, No. A20-1362
(Minn. Supreme Court) |
10/28/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Minnesota |
Vote-by-Mail (Mail
Voting Deadlines [for Applying, Receiving, Postmark]) |
Granted
Injunction. Sequestration of late ballots |
Trump/GOP |
10/29/20 |
Closed |
|
|
9 |
Donald J. Trump for President v. Gloria, No.
A-20-824153-C (NV District Court) |
11/03/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Nevada |
Requested
voting time extension |
Granted. Extended poll hours. |
Trump/GOP |
11/3/20 |
Closed |
|
|
10 |
In Re: Canvassing Observation, No. 7003 (PA Ct. Common
Pleas, Phil. Cnty) |
11/03/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Pennsylvania |
Poll observers do not have sufficient proximity
to canvassing. |
Denied
- Poll observer access |
Election
Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
In Re: Canvassing Observation, No. 1094 CD 2020 (PA
Commonwealth Ct) |
11/04/20 |
Appeal Granted
- Poll observer access |
Trump/GOP |
|
|
In Re: Canvassing Observation, No. 30 EAP 2020 (Penn.
Supreme Court) |
11/05/20 |
Reversed |
Election
Administrators |
|
|
Trump v. Boockvar, No. 30 EAP 2020 20-845 (US Supreme
Court) |
12/20/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
Election
Administrators |
|
|
11 |
Donald Trump for Pres. v. Benson, No. 20-000225-MZ (MI
Court of Claims) |
11/04/20 |
RULES & PROCESS |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail (Drop Boxes/Drop Off
Locations; Poll Observer Access) |
Dismissed - Lacked Timeliness; Moot |
Case Not Fully Heard |
12/11/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for President v. Benson, No. 355378 (MI
Appeals Court) |
11/30/20 |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for President v. Benson, No. 162320 (MI
Supreme Court) |
12/17/20 |
|
|
12 |
Donald J. Trump for President, Inc. v. Kathy Boockvar, et
al., No. 602 MD 2020 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania) |
11/04/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail (Sec
of State can not allow ID proof to be delayed by several days) |
Granted
Injunction. Late ballots without ID not counted. |
Trump/GOP |
11/12/20 |
Closed |
|
|
13 |
In re Enforcement of Election Laws and Securing Ballots
Cast or Received After 7:00 P.M. on November 3, 2020, No. SPCV20-00982 (GA
Superior Court) |
11/04/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Georgia |
Sequestration
of Absentee Ballots submitted after Election Day |
Denied
on statutory basis |
Election
Administrators |
11/5/20 |
Closed |
|
|
14 |
Donald J. Trump for Pres., Inc. v. Philadelphia Cnty. Bd.
of Elections, No. 2:20-cv-05533-PD (Eastern District Court Pennsylvania) |
11/05/20 |
PROCESS |
NA |
Pennsylvania |
Poll
observers at early voting locations |
Voluntarily
Dismissed (withdrawn) |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
11/5/20 |
Closed |
|
|
15 |
Donald J. Trump for President Inc. v. Montgomery County
Board of Elections... |
11/05/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
No
addresses on 600± absentee ballots |
Denied
on statutory basis |
Election
Administrators |
11/13/20 |
Closed |
|
|
16 |
Donald J. Trump for President Inc. v. Hobbs, No.
CV2020-014248 (AZ Super) |
11/07/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Arizona |
Cancelled
votes |
Dismissed
- Moot |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
11/16/20 |
Closed |
|
|
17 |
Donald J. Trump for Pres., Inc. v. Boockvar, No.
4:20-cv-02078 (M.D. PA) |
11/09/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Pennsylvania |
Insufficient poll watching of absentee ballots,
etc. |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing |
Case Not Fully Heard |
11/27/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for Pres., Inc. v. Boockvar, No. 20-3371
(3rd Circuit) |
11/22/20 |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for President v. Boockvar, No. 20-3371
(3rd Cir Appeals) |
11/23/20 |
Appellants
seek review of the district court for denying their Motion to Amend … |
|
|
18 |
Donald J. Trump for President Inc. v. Bucks County Board
of Elections, No. 20-05786-35 (Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Bucks
County) |
11/09/20 |
PROCESS |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail Issue: 2177 Ballots were
objected to for various reasons — e.g. unsigned, etc. It then came down to 69
ballots received in unsealed envelopes. |
Denied on statutory basis |
Election Administrators |
12/8/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for President Inc. v. Bucks County Board
of Elections, No. 1191 C.D. 2020 (PA Commonwealth Court) |
11/20/20 |
|
|
Donald J. Trump for President Inc. v. Bucks County Board
of Elections, Nos. 174/676 MAL 2020 (PA Supreme Court) |
11/21/20 |
|
|
19 |
In Re: Canvass of Absentee and Mail-In Ballots of
November 3, 2020 General Election, No. 20110894 (Penn. Ct. Common Pleas,
Philadelphia County) |
11/10/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail Issues (Poll Observer Access;
Signature Verification Standards; Notice/Cure for Mismatches Missing
Signature or Mistakes) |
Denied - Interpretation of Election Code (voter
did not print name nor include street address) |
Election Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
"
" " "
No. 20110895 (Penn. Ct. Common Pleas, Philadelphia County) |
11/10/20 |
|
|
"
" " "
No. 20110896 (Penn. Ct. Common Pleas, Philadelphia County) |
11/10/20 |
|
|
"
" " "
No. 20110897 (Penn. Ct. Common Pleas, Philadelphia County) |
11/10/20 |
|
|
"
" " "
No. 20110898 (Penn. Ct. Common Pleas, Philadelphia County) |
11/10/20 |
|
|
"
" " "
No. 31 EAP 2020 |
11/18/20 |
|
|
Trump v. Boockvar, Nos. 31 EAP 2020, 32 EAP 2020, 33 EAP
2020, 34 EAP 2020, 35 EAP 2020, 29 WAP 2020 (US Supreme Court) |
12/20/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
20 |
Donald J. Trump for President Inc. v. Benson, No.
1:20-cv-01083 (W.D. Mich.) |
11/11/20 |
PROCESS |
NA |
Michigan |
For
Wayne County not to certify their results |
Voluntarily
Withdrawn |
Trump/GOP:
Wayne County votes not certified |
11/19/20 |
Closed |
|
|
21 |
Trump v. Evers, No. 2020AP1971-OA (Wisconsin Supreme
Court) |
12/01/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Wisconsin |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution; Notice/Cure for
Mismatches Missing Signature or Mistakes) |
Dismissed
- Jurisdiction |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/3/20 |
Closed |
|
|
22 |
Trump v. Wisconsin Elections Commissions, No.
2:20-cv-01785 (E.D. Wis.) |
12/02/20 |
PROCESS |
TBD |
Wisconsin |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution) |
Denied: Moot; Statutes not violated. |
Case Not Fully Heard |
3/8/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Trump v. Wisconsin Elections Commissions, No. 20-3414
(7th Circuit Court) |
12/12/20 |
Authority To Act (Electors Clause) |
Denied:
Laches; Statutes not violated |
|
|
Trump v. Wisconsin Elections Commissions, No. 20-883 (US
Supreme Court) |
12/30/20 |
Case Not Heard |
|
|
23 |
Trump v. Biden, No. 2020CV007092 (WI Superior Court,
Milwaukee County) |
12/03/20 |
RULES & PROCESS |
NO |
Wisconsin |
Recount;
Illegal Ballots Cast |
Court
affirmed recount |
Election Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Trump v. Biden, No. 2020AP2038 (Wisconsin Supreme Court) |
12/11/20 |
Illegal Ballots Cast |
Denied:
Laches; Statutes not violated |
|
|
Trump v. Biden, No. 20-882 (US Supreme Court) |
12/29/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
24 |
Trump v. Raffensperger, No. 2020CV343255 (GA Superior
Court, Fulton County) |
12/04/20 |
RULES |
NA |
Georgia |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution) |
Voluntarily
Dismissed (withdrawn) |
Case Not Fully Heard |
1/7/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Trump v. Raffensperger, No. S21M0561 (Georgia Supreme
Court) |
12/11/20 |
Authority To
Act (Other) |
Dismissed -
Jurisdiction |
|
|
25 |
Trump v. Toulouse Oliver, No. 1:20-cv-01289 (District
Court, New Mexico) |
12/14/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
New
Mexico |
Vote-by-Mail (Drop
Boxes/Drop Off Locations) |
Voluntarily
Withdrawn |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/15/20 |
Closed |
|
|
26 |
Trump v. Kemp, No. 1:20-cv-05310-MHC (North District
Georgia) |
12/31/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Georgia |
Authority
To Act (Electors Clause) |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
1/5/21 |
Closed |
|
|
|
Filings with Trump as Plaintiff Subtotals = |
26 |
|
8 |
Note: Trump prevailed in 4
out of 8 cases decided on the merits |
Trump as
Plaintiff: Active = |
0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
# |
Election
Integrity Cases with GOP, et al as Plaintiffs |
Date
Filed |
Topic
* |
Decided
on Merits ** |
State |
Issue(s) |
Disposition |
Ruling
Favored |
Date
of Last Order |
Status |
|
|
27 |
Jefferson v. Dane County, No. 2020AP000557 – OA
(Wisconsin Supreme Court) |
3/27/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Wisconsin |
Misleading
info re absentee ballots |
Granted
motion for TRO |
Trump/GOP |
12/14/20 |
Closed |
|
|
28 |
Curtin v. VA State Bd. of Elections, No. 1:20-cv-00546
(E.D. Virginia) |
5/13/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Virginia |
Absentee
ballots increases voter fraud |
Dismissed
- Laches |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
9/7/20 |
Closed |
|
|
29 |
Ritchie v. Polis, No. 2020CV31708 (Colorado District
Court, Denver) |
5/18/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Colorado |
Objected to the Governor being able to change
some of the Vote-by-Mail rules. |
Denied on statutory basis |
Election
Administrators |
9/1/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Ritchie v. Polis, No. 20CA983 (Colorado Court Appeals) |
6/01/20 |
|
|
Ritchie v. Polis, No. 20SC453 (Colorado Supreme Court) |
6/10/20 |
Overturned |
Trump/GOP |
|
|
30 |
RNC v. Newsom, No. 2:20-cv-01055 (E.D. California) |
5/24/20 |
RULES |
YES |
California |
Governor can
not bypass Legislature |
Withdrawn
as Governor complied |
Trump/GOP |
9/1/20 |
Closed |
|
|
31 |
Davis v. Benson, No. 20-000099-MM (MI Court of Claims) |
5/28/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail (Other Vote-by-Mail Issue) [Consolidated with Black v. Benson and Cooper-Keel v. Benson.] |
Denied on statutory basis, as Plaintiff did not
show irreparable harm, etc. |
Case Not Fully Heard |
3/5/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Davis v. Benson, No. 1:20-cv-00768 (MI Western District
Court) |
8/13/20 |
|
|
Davis v. Benson, No. 354622 (Michigan Court of Appeals) |
8/14/20 |
|
|
Davis v. Benson, No. 1:20-cv-00981 (MI Western District
Court) |
10/14/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot |
|
|
32 |
Daunt v. Benson, Case 1:20-cv-00522-RJJ-RSK (MI Western
District Court) |
6/09/20 |
VOTER |
YES |
Michigan |
Clean-up,
purge voter rolls |
State
agreed to update voter rolls |
Trump/GOP |
2/16/21 |
Closed |
|
|
33 |
PA Democratic Party v. Boockvar #407-MD-2020 (PA
Commonwealth Court) |
7/10/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail (Mail Voting Deadlines [for
Applying, Receiving, Postmark], etc.) [Note:
plaintiff was Democratic Party] |
Partial victory |
Split Verdict |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
PA Democratic Party v. Boockvar, No. 133 MM 2020 (PA
Supreme Ct) |
8/16/20 |
|
|
Republican Party of PA v. Boockvar, Et Al., No. 20-542
(US Supreme Court) |
10/19/20 |
|
|
34 |
Reed-Pratt v. Winfrey, No. 3:20-cv-12129 (MI Eastern
District Court) |
8/08/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail: Unsolicited mailing of absentee
voter application |
Dismissed
as Legislation Pending |
Case Not Fully Heard |
1/19/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Reed-Pratt v. Winfrey, No. 20-1876 (6th Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
9/10/20 |
Sent back to
lower court |
|
|
Reed-Pratt v. Winfrey, No. 3:20-cv-12129 (MI Eastern
District Court) |
9/10/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot |
|
|
35 |
RNC v. Weipert, No. 06521 CVCV081957 (Iowa District
Court, Johnson County) |
8/10/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Iowa |
Vote-by-Mail (Signature
Verification Standards; Claim that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote
Dilution; Other Vote-by-Mail Issue) |
Corrective
Action Ordered |
Trump/GOP |
9/12/20 |
Closed |
|
|
36 |
RNC v. Gill, No. 03971 EQCV193154 (Iowa District Court,
Woodbury County) |
8/14/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Iowa |
Prepopulating of mail-in ballots |
Injunction
Granted |
Trump/GOP |
10/16/20 |
Closed |
|
|
RNC v. Gill, No. 20-1169 (Iowa Supreme Court) |
8/15/20 |
Stay Granted |
|
|
37 |
Election Integrity Fund v. Benson, No. 20-000169-MM (MI
Court of Claims) |
8/24/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail:
Allowing online applications |
Consolidated:
See line #69 |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/11/20 |
Consolidated |
|
|
38 |
Texas v. Hollins, No. 2020-52383 (TX District Court,
Harris County) |
8/31/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Texas |
County Clerk sending mail-in ballots to all voters in the
election. |
Insufficient evidence of harm |
GOP Defendant |
10/17/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Texas v. Hollins, No. 14-20-00627-CV (Texas Court of
Appeals) |
9/14/20 |
|
|
Texas v. Hollins, Nos. 20-0715 & 20-0729 (Texas
Supreme Court) |
9/22/20 |
Over turned
and agreed w Plaintiff |
|
|
39 |
Election Integrity Proj of NV v. NV, No. A-20-820510-C
(NV Dist Ct, Clark Cnty) |
9/01/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Nevada |
New Nevada statute AB4 increased likelihood of
voter fraud |
Dismissed - Lacked Ripeness |
Case Not Fully Heard |
10/18/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Election Integrity Project of NV v. Nevada, No. 81847 (NV
Superior Court) |
9/25/20 |
|
|
40 |
Martel v. Condos, No. 5:20-cv-00131 (District of Vermont) |
9/04/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Vermont |
Sec
of State exceeded their authority |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
10/15/20 |
Closed |
|
|
41 |
Lamm v. Bullock, No. 6:20-cv-00067 (District Court
Montana) |
9/09/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Montana |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim that the Governor
exceeded his authority, etc.) |
Insufficient
Evidence |
Election Administrators |
10/8/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Lamm v. Bullock, No. 20-35847 (9th Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
9/30/20 |
Appeal |
|
|
Lamm v. Bullock, No. 20A61 (US Supreme Court) |
10/06/20 |
Denied - No
Opinion |
|
|
42 |
Carson et al v. Simon, No. 0:20-cv-02030 (District Court
Minnesota) |
9/22/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Minnesota |
Objected to State not enforcing Minnesota’s
Election-Day ballot receipt deadline |
Denied
request |
Trump/GOP |
11/5/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Carson v. Simon, No. 20-3139 (8th Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
10/20/20 |
Granted:
Reversed lower court |
|
|
43 |
Monmouth County Republican Committee v. Way, No.
3:20-cv-13914 (District Court of NJ) & No. MON-L-003019-20 (NJ Superior
Court, Monmouth County) |
9/24/20 |
RULES |
NO |
New
Jersey |
Various
absentee ballot issues |
Consolidated
with Murphy case |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
10/20/20 |
Consolidated |
|
|
44 |
Penn. Voters Alliance v. Centre County, No. 4:20-cv-01761
(M.D. PA) |
9/25/20 |
RULES |
TBD |
Pennsylvania |
Private Funding Encourages Illegal Ballots. [At Supreme Court combined w similar
lawsuits from other states: WI, MI, MN, IO, TX, GA, SC.] |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing & Laches |
Case Not Fully Heard |
1/11/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Penn. Voters Alliance v. Centre County, No. 20-3175 (3d
Circuit Appeals) |
10/22/20 |
|
|
Penn. Voters Alliance v. Centre Cnty., No. 20-553 (US
Supreme Court) |
10/26/20 |
Petition
denied |
|
|
45 |
Moore v. Circosta, No. 4:20-cv-00182 (Eastern District of
NC) |
9/26/20 |
RULES |
NO |
North Carolina |
Plaintiffs oppose relaxation of voting
requirements due to COVID-19 |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing & Laches |
Case Not Fully Heard |
12/6/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Moore v. Circosta, No. 20-02107 (4th Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
10/15/20 |
|
|
Moore v. Circosta, No. 20A72 (US Supreme Court) |
10/22/20 |
|
|
46 |
Wise v. N.C. State Bd. of Elections, No. 5:20-cv-00505
(E.D. NC) |
9/26/20 |
RULES & PROCESS |
NO |
North Carolina |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution, etc.) |
At US Supreme Court this case was consolidated
with Moore v. Circosta |
See Moore v Circosta case |
12/6/20 |
Consolidated |
|
|
Wise v. NC State Bd. of Elections, No. 20-2063 (4th
Circuit Appeals) |
10/18/20 |
Extension of voting deadlines |
|
|
Wise v. NC State Bd. of Elections, No. 20A71 (US Supreme
Court) |
10/26/20 |
|
|
47 |
Mi Familia Vota v. Hobbs, No. 2:20-cv-01903 (Arizona
District Court) |
9/30/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Arizona |
Objection to State's voter deadline |
Supported by statute, but overturned on
technical grounds |
Case Not Fully Heard |
10/20/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Mi Familia Vota v. Hobbs, No. 20-16932 (9th Circuit Court
of Appeals) |
10/13/20 |
|
|
48 |
Judicial Watch v. Griswold, No. 1:20-cv-02992 (Colorado
District Court) |
10/05/20 |
PROCESS |
YES |
Colorado |
Objection to
inaccurate voter files |
Colorado
agreed to fix issues |
GOP
Defendant |
5/30/23 |
Closed |
|
|
49 |
Arnett v. NC State Bd of Elections, No. 20 CVS 00570 (NC
Sup Ct, Duplin Cnty) |
10/05/20 |
PROCESS |
TBD |
North
Carolina |
Transparency
in counting Absentee Ballots |
Court
said mediation is necessary |
TBD |
10/29/20 |
Closed |
|
|
50 |
Reed v. Virginia Dept. of Elections No. 20-622 (Frederick
Circuit Court) |
10/09/20 |
RULES |
YES |
Virginia |
Enforce statutes governing the acceptance of
absentee ballots with respect to postmarks |
Granted |
GOP
Defendant |
1/13/21 |
Closed |
|
|
51 |
PILF v. Boockvar No. 1:20-cv-1905 (Middle District Court
of PA) |
10/15/20 |
VOTER |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
Clean-up,
purge voter rolls, esp. deceased |
State
agreed to update voter rolls |
GOP
Defendant |
4/7/21 |
Closed |
|
|
52 |
Bognet v. Boockvar, No. 3:20-cv-00215 (Western District
Pennsylvania) |
10/22/20 |
RULES |
TBD |
Pennsylvania |
Illegal extension of voting deadline |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing |
Election Administrators |
4/19/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Bognet v. Boockvar, No. 20-3214 (3rd Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
10/29/20 |
|
|
Bognet v. Boockvar No. 20-740 (US Supreme Court) |
11/20/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot |
|
|
53 |
Kraus v. Cegavske, No. 20 OC 00142 1B (Nev. Dist. Ct.,
Carson City) |
10/23/20 |
RULES & PROCESS |
YES |
Nevada |
Vote-by-Mail (Poll Observer Access;
Signature Verification Standards; Notice/Cure for Mismatches Missing
Signature or Mistakes) |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Split Verdict |
11/10/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Kraus v. Cegavske, No. 82018 (Nevada Supreme Court) |
11/03/20 |
Agreed to more
poll watchers |
|
|
54 |
Hotze v. Hollins No. 20-0863 (Supreme Court of Texas) |
10/27/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Texas |
Whether drive-through voting should be allowed |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing |
Election Administrators |
12/17/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Hotze v. Hollins
No. 20-20574 (U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit) |
11/02/20 |
|
|
55 |
Nevada Republican Central Committee v. Clark County, No.
A-20-8238210W (Nevada District Court, Clark County) |
10/27/20 |
MISC |
YES |
Nevada |
Request
for various voter data |
Mostly
Granted |
Trump/GOP |
11/2/20 |
Closed |
|
|
56 |
In re Enforcement of Election Laws and Securing Ballots
Cast or Received After 7:00 P.M. on November 3, 2020, No. SPCV20-00982
(Georgia Superior Court) |
11/04/20 |
PROCESS |
YES |
Georgia |
Sequester
ballots after election day |
Denied
- no evidence of law violations |
Election
Administrators |
11/19/20 |
Closed |
|
|
57 |
Costantino v. Detroit, No. 20-014780-AW (3rd Circuit
Court) |
11/09/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail (Multiple process
deficiencies) |
Insufficient
Evidence |
Election Administrators |
11/24/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Costantino v. Detroit, No. 355443 (Michigan Court of
Appeals) |
11/16/20 |
Denied on
statutory basis |
|
|
Costantino v. Detroit, No. 162245 (Michigan Supreme
Court) |
11/17/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot |
|
|
58 |
Pirkle v. Wolf, No. 4:20-cv-02088-MWB (Middle District
Pennsylvania) |
11/10/20 |
RULES
& PROCESS |
NA |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail (Signature
Verification Standards; Poll Observer Access) |
Voluntarily
Dismissed (withdrawn) |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
11/16/20 |
Closed |
|
|
59 |
Bally v. Whitmer, No. 1:20-cv-1088 (Western District
Michigan) |
11/11/20 |
RULES
& PROCESS |
NA |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution; Observer Access) |
Voluntarily
Dismissed (withdrawn) |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
11/16/20 |
Closed |
|
|
60 |
Ziccarelli v. Allegheny County B of E, No. GD-20-11654
(PA Common Pleas) |
11/12/20 |
RULES & PROCESS |
TBD |
Pennsylvania |
Vote-by-Mail (Failure to write name,
address, and date on outer envelope, etc.) |
Now at Supreme Court, consolidated with PA
"Canvassing" cases above |
See PA Canvassing case |
11/23/20 |
Consolidated |
|
|
Ziccarelli v. Allegheny County B of E, No. 1162 CD 2020
(PA Common. Ct.) |
11/19/20 |
|
|
Ziccarelli v. Allegheny County B of E, No. 29 WAP 2020
(PA Supreme Court) |
11/20/20 |
|
|
61 |
Lin Wood v. Raffensperger, No. 1:20-cv-04651-SDG (North
District Georgia) |
11/13/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Georgia |
State allowed procedures that are different from
the Georgia Election Code |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing |
Election Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Lin Wood v. Raffensperger, No. 20-14418 (11th Circuit) |
11/24/20 |
|
|
Lin Wood v. Raffensperger, No. 20-799 (US Supreme Court) |
12/08/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
62 |
Law v. Whitmer, No. 10 OC 00163 1B (Nev. Dist. Ct.,
Carson City) |
11/17/20 |
MACHINE |
YES |
Nevada |
Challenge to Voting Machinery / Hardware /
Software: Accepting Invalid Signatures |
Denied on statutory basis. (Discovery opposed
and not granted.) |
Election Administrators |
12/17/20 |
Closed |
|
|
Law v. Whitmer, No. 82178 (Nev. Supreme Court) |
12/10/20 |
|
|
63 |
Kelly v. Pennsylvania, No. 620 MD 2020 (PA Commonwealth
Court) |
11/21/20 |
RULES & PROCESS |
TBD |
Pennsylvania |
Legality of No Excuse Absentee voting |
Injunction
Granted |
Trump/GOP |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Kelly v. Pennsylvania, No. No. 68 MAP 2020 (PA Supreme
Court) |
11/25/20 |
Dismissed -
Timeliness (Laches) |
Election Administrators |
|
|
Kelly v. Pennsylvania, No. 20A98 / 20-810 (US Supreme
Court) |
12/03/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
64 |
Kistner v. Simon No. A20-1486 (Minnesota Supreme Court) |
11/24/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Minnesota |
Vote
by Mail (Ballot harvesting; signature matching; etc.) |
Dismissed
- Timeliness (Laches) and Jurisdiction |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/4/20 |
Closed |
|
|
65 |
Bailey v. Antrim County No. 20-9238-C2 (Antrim Michigan
Circuit Court) |
11/25/20 |
MACHINE |
YES |
Michigan |
Voting machine improperly counted votes |
Discovery Granted: Defendant agreed with
Plaintiff's complaint |
Trump/GOP |
4/21/22 |
Closed |
|
|
Bailey v. Antrim County
(Appeals Court) |
4/21/22 |
|
|
66 |
Wood v. Raffensperger, No. 2020CV342959 (GA Superior
Court, Fulton County) |
11/25/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Georgia |
GA
should not have accepted a grant |
Dismissed
- Sovereign Immunity |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/7/20 |
Closed |
|
|
67 |
Pearson v. Kemp, No. 1:20-cv-04809-TCB (GA Northern
District) |
11/25/20 |
MACHINE |
NO |
Georgia |
Voting machine irregularities |
Dismissed - Jurisdiction |
Election Administrators |
1/19/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Pearson v. Kemp, No. 20-14480 (11th Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
11/25/20 |
|
|
In Re Pearson v. Kemp, No. 20-816 (US Supreme Court) |
12/03/20 |
Voluntarily
Dismissed (withdrawn) |
Case Not Fully
Heard |
|
|
68 |
King v. Whitmer, No. 2:20-cv-13134 (Eastern District of
Michigan) |
11/25/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail (Poll Observer Access; Ballots
were Forged or Altered) |
Dismissed - Timeliness (Laches) |
Election Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
King v. Whitmer, No. 20-2205 (6th Circuit Court of
Appeals) |
12/08/20 |
|
|
King v. Whitmer, No. 20-815 (US Supreme Court) |
12/11/20 |
Dismissed
- Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
69 |
Johnson v. Benson, No. 162286 (Michigan Supreme Court) |
11/26/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Michigan |
Vote-by-Mail (Other
Vote-by-Mail Issue) |
Dismissed
- Jurisdiction & Moot |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/9/20 |
Closed |
|
|
70 |
Mueller v. Jacobs, No. 2020AP1958-OA (Wisconsin Supreme
Court) |
11/27/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Wisconsin |
Vote-by-Mail (Ballot
drop boxes) |
Dismissed
- Moot |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/4/20 |
Closed |
|
|
71 |
Hahn v. Simon, No. 14-CV-20-4033 (Clay County District
Court) |
11/30/20 |
PROCESS
& VOTERS |
NO |
Minnesota |
Vote-by-Mail (e.g. Poll Observer Access).
Voter Irregularities (Duplicate Votes, etc.) |
Dismissed - Timeliness & Jurisdiction |
Election Administrators |
1/13/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Hahn v. Keeler, No. A20-1654 (Minnesota Supreme Court) |
1/13/21 |
|
|
72 |
Ward v. Jackson, No. CV2020-015285 (Ariz. Superior Court,
Maricopa County |
11/30/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Arizona |
Vote-by-Mail (e.g. Poll Observer Access,
Poll Observer Qualifications, etc.) |
No proof of fraud |
Election Administrators |
2/22/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Ward v. Jackson, No. CV-20-0343-AP/EL (Ariz. Supreme
Court) |
12/04/20 |
|
|
Ward v. Jackson, No. 20-809 (US Supreme Court) |
12/11/20 |
Dismissed -
Moot/ Cert Denied |
|
|
73 |
Braun v. Simon (+similar) No.
62-CV-20-5599/5600/5601/5602 (MN District Court) |
12/01/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Minnesota |
Alleges
statutory violations and irregularities in the post-election review process. |
Dismissed
- No Explanation |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/18/20 |
Closed |
|
|
74 |
Feehan v. Wisconsin Elections Commission, No.
2:20-cv-1771 (E.D. Wis.) |
12/01/20 |
RULES
& PROCESS |
NO |
Wisconsin |
Vote-by-Mail (Failure
to Include ID Documentation) |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing and Jurisdiction |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/9/20 |
Closed |
|
|
75 |
Bowyer v. Ducey, No. 2:20-cv-02321-DJH (District Court of
AZ) |
12/02/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Arizona |
Authority
To Act (Elections Clause, etc.) |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/9/20 |
Closed |
|
|
76 |
Metcalfe v. Wolf, No. 636 MD 2020 (PA Commonwealth Court) |
12/04/20 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Pennsylvania |
Officials
violated portions of Election Code |
Dismissed
- Laches and Jurisdiction |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/13/20 |
Closed |
|
|
77 |
Burk v. Ducey, No. CV202001869 (AZ Superior Court, Pinal
County) |
12/07/20 |
MACHINE |
NO |
Arizona |
Illegal ballots inserted into mail system which
were counted while Plaintiff was denied her right to vote. |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing |
Case Not Fully Heard |
5/3/21 |
Closed |
|
|
Burk v. Ducey, No. CV-20-0349-AP/EL (Arizona Supreme
Court) |
12/16/20 |
|
|
Burk v. Ducey, (US Supreme Court) |
3/03/21 |
|
|
78 |
Texas v. Penn, Wisc, Mich, Georgia, No. 22O155 (US
Supreme Court) |
12/07/20 |
RULES |
NO |
Various |
Violations
of State Election Laws |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
12/15/20 |
Closed |
|
|
79 |
Still v. Raffensperger, No. 2020CV343711 (GA Superior
Court, Fulton Cnty.) |
12/12/20 |
RULES |
NA |
Georgia |
Vote-by-Mail (Claim
that Mail Voting Leads to Fraud and/or Vote Dilution) |
Voluntarily
Dismissed (withdrawn) |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
1/7/21 |
Closed |
|
|
80 |
O'Rourke, et al v. Dominion, et al No. 1:20-cv-3747
(Colorado District Court) |
12/22/20 |
MACHINE + |
NO |
Colorado |
Use unreliable voting machines, etc., etc. |
Dismissed - Lacked Standing |
Case Not Fully Heard |
5/9/23 |
Closed |
|
|
O'Rourke, et al v. Dominion, et al No. 1:20-cv-3747 (US
Appeals, Tenth Circuit) |
12/23/21 |
|
|
81 |
Favorito v. Cooney, No. 2020CV343938 (GA Superior Ct,
Fulton Cnty) |
12/23/20 |
PROCESS |
YES |
Georgia |
Improper
ballot counting: ask to inspect ballots |
Granted |
Trump/GOP |
5/21/21 |
Closed |
|
|
82 |
Election Integrity Project v. Padilla, No. 2:21-cv-32
(District Court, C.D. California) |
1/04/21 |
RULES & MACHINE |
TBD |
California |
Violations of State and Federal Election Laws;
Voting machine irregularities |
Lower court dismissed all claims. Case is
currently under appeal |
TBD |
9/14/23 |
Active |
|
|
Election Integrity Project v. Weber, No. 2:21-cv-32 (9th
Circuit Ct of Appeals) |
9/27/21 |
|
|
83 |
Genetski & MI GOP v. Benson, No. 20-216-MM (Michigan
Court of Claims) |
1/20/21 |
PROCESS |
YES |
Michigan |
Violations
of State Election Laws re signature verification, etc. |
Granted |
Trump/GOP |
3/9/21 |
Closed |
|
|
84 |
Daugherty v. Fulton, No. 2021CV344953 (GA Superior Court,
Fulton Cnty) |
1/25/21 |
PROCESS |
TBD |
Georgia |
GA elections should
not have been certified |
Dismissed -
Timeliness (Laches) |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
8/2/21 |
Closed |
|
|
85 |
VoterGA v. Gwinnett Cty Bd of Elections, No. 20-A-08626-2
(Superior Ct, Gwinnett) |
3/22/21 |
PROCESS |
YES |
Georgia |
Improper
ballot counting: ask to inspect ballots |
Granted |
Trump/GOP |
1/24/22 |
Closed |
|
|
86 |
Rogan O Handley v. Weber, No. 2:21-cv-04954 (District
Court C.D. California) |
6/17/21 |
RULES |
TBD |
California |
State
tried to miseducate voters. |
Currently
being appealed |
TBD |
6/17/21 |
Active |
|
|
87 |
VoterGA v. State of Georgia, No. 2021CV353604 (Superior
Ct, Fulton) |
8/24/21 |
MACHINE |
TBD |
Georgia |
Machines
not legal |
Judge ruled
that there was no dispute. |
A
draw |
5/31/22 |
Closed |
|
|
88 |
Perdue v. Barron (Superior Court of Fulton County, GA) |
12/09/21 |
PROCESS |
NO |
Georgia |
Questionable
absentee ballots |
Dismissed
- Lacked Standing |
Case
Not Fully Heard |
2/5/24 |
Closed |
|
|
|
Filings with Trump not Plaintiff Subtotals = |
62 |
|
20 |
Note: GOP Plaintiff
prevailed in 17 out of 20 cases decided on the merits |
Trump not
plaintiff: Active = |
2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
# |
Election
Integrity Cases with Trump/GOP as Defendant |
Date Filed |
Topic * |
Decided on
Merits ** |
State |
Issue(s) |
Disposition |
Ruling Favored |
Date of Last
Order |
Status |
|
|
89 |
Washington v. Trump, No. 1:20-cv-03127 (Eastern District
Washington) |
8/17/20 |
MISC |
YES |
DC |
Vote-by-Mail (several
states vs USPS) |
Injunction
Granted |
Plaintiff |
9/18/20 |
Closed |
|
|
90 |
Pierson v. Stepien, No. 1:20-cv-09266 (Southern District
NY) |
11/04/20 |
PROCESS |
YES |
New
York |
Recount
procedures |
Defective
claims |
Trump/GOP |
11/13/20 |
Closed |
|
|
91 |
Michigan Welfare Rights Organization v. Trump, No.
1:20-cv-03388 (D.D.C.) |
11/20/20 |
RULES |
TBD |
DC |
Trump
trying to disenfranchise minorities |
Currently
being appealed |
TBD |
9/21/23 |
Active |
|
|
92 |
Maricopa v. Fann No. CV 2020-016840 (Superior Ct of AZ,
Maricopa Cty) |
12/29/20 |
RULES |
YES |
DC |
County
objecting to a Senate investigation |
Senate
requests are legal |
Trump/GOP |
2/25/21 |
Closed |
|
|
93 |
Savage v. Trump, No. 211002495 (Philadelphia County
Court) |
10/01/21 |
RULES |
YES |
Pennsylvania |
Election
official accused of fraud |
Plaintiff
withdrew complaint |
Trump, et al |
2/28/24 |
Closed |
|
|
|
Filings with Trump, et. al. as Defendant = |
5 |
|
4 |
Note: GOP Defendant
prevailed in 3 out of 4 cases decided on the merits |
Trump as
defendant: Active = |
1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
For All 2020 Presidential
Election Cases |
# of Decisions |
|
Decided on Merits ** |
|
|
|
|
|
Active Status |
|
|
|
Grand Totals = |
93 |
|
32 |
Note: Trump and/or the GOP
plaintiff prevailed in 24 out
of 32 cases decided
on the merits (75%). |
|
3 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Main References: |
|
*Main Topics are: a) Rules and Regulation legalities
or interpretation (e.g. about absentee
ballots); b) Process
illegalities (officials correcting ballot errors, etc.); |
|
|
|
|
Stanford Healthy
Elections Tracker |
|
c) Voter Improprieties (e.g.
non-citizens voting, non-registered citizens voting, deceased parties voting,
registered voters voting twice, etc.) |
|
|
|
|
|
Scotus blog
Election Litigation Tracker |
|
and/or d) Voting Machine irregularities (e.g. an algorithm changing the actual results, etc.). |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ballotpedia: Pre-
and Post-Election Lawsuits |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brennan Center
for Justice |
|
The Totals for each
Primary Topic are: Rules = 51;
Process = 33; Voter = 3; and Machine = 6. (The total is more than the number of
cases, as some cases had more than one Topic.) |
|
|
|
Here is the
Evidence |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Court Listener |
|
|
**Decided
on Merits means the Plaintiff was able to argue
the facts of the case, and, if applicable, given opportunity to present evidence via Discovery. |
|
|
|
|
Public Interest
Legal Foundation |
|
|
(For example, Discovery might entail an
independent investigation to verify the accuracy of the claimed voting
malfeasance, impropriety, etc.) |
|
|
|
|
Wikipedia Pre-
and Post-Election 2020 Election Lawsuits |
|
|
For the lawsuits that were voluntarily
dismissed, we entered "NA" in the Merits column. For those cases
still open, we entered "TBD". |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note
1: Some Non-Merit reasons for stopping lawsuits
from going forward are for: a) Standing, b) Timing [Laches], c) Judicial
authority [Jurisdiction], and d)
Moot (e.g. not enough malfeasance to make a difference). In each of these
situations, the case was not fully heard. |
|
|
|
In US Supreme Court Cases, "Cert Denied" means that the case
will not be heard, and the lower court's decision stands. This happens in
90%± of cases submitted to SCOTUS. It does not necessarily mean SCOTUS agrees
with the lower court. |
|
|
|
In the "Dismissed Moot/Cert Denied" cases above, the
majority of the judges did not state why they would not hear these cases.
However, Judge Thomas wrote a strong argument against denying Cert here, and
he objected to other judges using Moot as an excuse. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note 2: Disposition breakdown of the 93 lawsuits: Non-Merit = 46 (beige); To Be Determined (TBD: active) = 3 (white); Trump/GOP Statutory Wins = 24
(green);
Trump Statutory Losses = 8 (red); Voluntarily withdrawn
(due to consolidation, etc.) = 12 (blue). |
|
|
|
|
[Two cases resulted in a split verdict. One was labelled as a loss,
and the other as a win.] |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note 3: Since several lawsuits were based on new election regulations
(e.g. pertaining to absentee ballots), reportedly due to COVID-19 concerns,
this is a list of such changes (by state): |
here. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note 4: One of the several complexities in putting together such a
list, is how to handle cases that are appealed. For example, should one case
appealed twice be treated as three cases or one? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
The
argument for treating them as three cases is due to the facts that: the
judges are different, the amount of evidence presented may be different, etc.
In our initial versions of this list, we took this approach. |
|
|
|
|
|
However,
there are downsides to that treatment: it artificially inflates the
appearance of actual cases litigated; do we indicate that this is one case
open or three? etc. Although either way has merits, we are now counting such
situations as one case. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note 5: Another complexity is
to sort through the multitude of cases filed having to do with 2020 election
issues. E.g. the Stanford site (see above) lists 470± such cases (including
appeals). We just selected those that directly applied to the Presidential
contest. |
|
|
|
That said, we make no claim that this is the entirety of 2020
Presidential election-related cases, but rather those that we were able to
find from the several sources cited. If we missed any relevant cases, please
send us an email and we will gladly do an update. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note 6: Some other 2020 Election Reports by the same team of
independent volunteer experts are found at: |
election-integrity.info |
The two primary authors here are Ray Blehar and
John Droz. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
For any questions, suggestions or improvements to
this list — or to sign up for our popular, free (every two weeks) Media Balance Newsletter (which covers Elections to Energy
& COVID to Climate): |
email physicist John Droz, jr. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|